Hawaiʻi residents with a criminal record have had one route to keep an old conviction off a background check: petition a court, one record at a time. On November 17, a coalition launched a campaign to change that, asking the Legislature to write automatic record shielding into law during the 2027 legislative session. The difference between those two systems is the whole proposal, and it is worth understanding before the session opens rather than after.
What the Coalition Launched
More than 60 advocates gathered in Hilo on Tuesday, November 17, to urge state legislators to pass a law in the upcoming session that would expand opportunities for residents with criminal records who have earned their second chances. The law would streamline the process of shielding eligible arrest or conviction records for people who have completed their sentences and remained crime-free.
The coalition's case is economic as much as legal. It says the law would boost the state's economy by expanding the workforce and removing barriers to employment, housing, and educational opportunities. The mechanism is specific: "A record-shielding law in Hawaiʻi would mean certain types of past arrest or conviction records no longer appear on online background checks, while law enforcement agencies would retain access." It would also enable the use of technology to identify eligible records and automate shielding, with human oversight.
The Problem the Campaign Points At
Hawaiʻi law already allows some records to be shielded, but only through a petition process that the coalition describes as complex, expensive, and out of reach for many people who qualify. That single sentence contains the campaign's core argument: a system that works one record at a time, one petition at a time, and one person's expense at a time, reaches a fraction of the people it is meant to serve.
The scale is what makes the gap hard to ignore. More than one in four Hawaiʻi adults has an arrest or conviction record that appears on standard background checks, according to data provided by the coalition. Its news release put the consequence plainly: "People with records experience stigma and discrimination that prevents them from getting hired or renting a home."
Automatic shielding changes who does the work. Under a petition process, a person identifies their own record, assembles proof of eligibility, pays a cost, and waits. Under the model the coalition proposes, the state identifies which records qualify and shields them. Whether that produces the same outcomes depends entirely on the criteria the Legislature writes into the statute, which is why the details of a bill matter more than a launch event.
The Numbers Behind the Campaign
Hawaiʻi Island Rep. David Tarnas, who chairs the Hawaiʻi House Committee on Judiciary and Hawaiian Affairs, framed it as a constituency issue rather than a policy abstraction: "This is a major issue that affects more than 315,000 people in our state. These are our families, friends, and neighbors." A second outlet that covered the same launch headlined the proposal as one that could help 300,000 residents, the same figure rounded down for a headline.
New research from The Clean Slate Initiative, a national bipartisan nonprofit organization, finds that arrest and conviction records are associated with $440 billion in lost annual earnings nationwide. In Hawaiʻi, those earnings losses total an estimated $2.2 billion each year. To date, 14 states and Washington, D.C., have passed Clean Slate laws, making more than 18 million people eligible for full or partial record relief across the United States. Data from these states show that state-initiated record relief helps people go back to school, find better-paying jobs, and improve family stability.
Who Is Behind the Push
Tarnas plans to work with other legislators to advance the bill in the upcoming session. The campaign also has someone with standing in a body that already has a say in what the statute should look like. Michelle Manalo, a member of the Clean Slate Hawaiʻi coalition, also serves on the Hawaiʻi Clean Slate Expungement Task Force, which was established by the Legislature in 2024 to make recommendations on a state-initiated record-shielding law. The task force is expected to deliver its recommendations ahead of the 2027 legislative session.
Manalo described the campaign in personal terms: "Like many of us here, I have served my time, demonstrated accountability, and rehabilitated my life. A Clean Slate law would create a pathway for people like me to have a fair shot at earning a living wage, supporting our families, and contributing to our communities." The task force's own recommendations may carry more weight with legislators than an outside coalition's would, which is one reason the timeline matters.
Employers are part of the coalition's argument. Hillary Lapre, Director of Operations at Little Caesars Hawaiʻi, said a Clean Slate law would "help employers by unlocking a large, underutilized segment of the workforce, helping fill open positions during tight labor markets." She also said it would "help individuals in my position to evaluate candidates based on current skills rather than past mistakes."
What It Would and Would Not Do
It would not erase a conviction. The mechanism the coalition describes is shielding: eligible records would no longer appear on online background checks, while law enforcement agencies would retain access. That is a meaningful difference for anyone turned down because of what a background check surfaced, and also a real limitation for anyone who needs to know the record is still there.
It would not replace the petition route either. Nothing in the campaign changes what a Hawaiʻi court can do today. Until the Legislature acts, the petition process described in the coalition's release remains the mechanism available to an individual person with a record in Hawaiʻi, along with its cost and its complexity.
It is not yet law, and nothing in the launch makes it law. A statute defines who qualifies, which records count, and what the state does about records it shields. Every detail that decides your case is a detail that has not been written yet.
What to Watch
The task force's recommendations, expected ahead of the 2027 session, are the first substantive signal. Then whether legislators introduce a bill at all. Then the bill itself, because the eligibility criteria and the automated-shielding mechanism will determine who is covered and who is not.
A law that does not exist yet cannot shield anyone's record. For now the petition route is the one that exists, and the value of the campaign is the attention it brings to a question of scale: how many people who qualify for shielding never get far enough to claim it.