Indiana State Police have charged Heather Ann Textor, 41, of Lowell, Indiana, with 42 felony counts and three misdemeanors alleging that she collected money from people seeking to clear criminal records, created fraudulent court documents, and told clients their legal problems had been resolved. The alleged scheme ran for years, and its most serious consequences were not financial: investigators say some people were arrested or incarcerated after relying on paperwork indicating their records had been cleared or their driving privileges restored, when no valid court action had ever occurred.
What investigators say the scheme involved
The Indiana State Police Organized Crime and Corruption Unit began the investigation in 2023 after the agency's expungement unit was alerted to suspicious paperwork. The documents appeared to establish that certain records had been legally expunged, but investigators found inconsistencies involving court records, judicial signatures, and official identification numbers. In one case, an identification number on a document was linked to a different person, and court clerks could not locate corresponding expungement orders. As the inquiry expanded, detectives identified additional paperwork involving expungements and specialized driving privileges, including documents with alleged forged judges' signatures and documents naming attorneys who had not agreed to represent the people listed on them.
How the money moved and why the firm's records did not catch it
Textor worked as a legal secretary at the Merrillville law firm Weiss, Schmidgall and Hires, P.C. People seeking expungement help commonly paid between about $800 and $1,500 for services they believed the firm was providing. Investigators say Textor sometimes accepted cash and issued receipts never entered into the firm's computerized client-management system, so other employees reviewing the firm's records would not find evidence the individuals were legitimate clients. Electronic payment accounts in the firm's name were also used to funnel money into personal accounts, the basis for the financial fraud and theft charges. Police allege that when clients questioned delays, Textor gave explanations that reinforced the belief the work was being handled. The law firm has cooperated with investigators; authorities have not accused the firm of participating.
What happened to the people who paid
One alleged victim, Lamar Cheairs, told ABC7 Chicago that he sought help in 2023 to clear his record after serving time for offenses he committed earlier in life, and paid $980. Roughly a year later, he attempted to legally purchase a firearm and discovered through the background check that his record had not been expunged as he had believed. He later obtained help and was eventually able to clear his record. Indiana State Police say at least two individuals faced driving-related issues they believed had been resolved; some kept driving believing they were permitted to, and when they encountered law enforcement they discovered unresolved cases or outstanding arrest warrants. Police also described cases in which individuals were incarcerated after relying on fraudulent documents. The harm did not surface at the moment of the fraud. It surfaced months or years later, in a background check, a traffic stop, or an arrest.
The charges, and where the case stands
According to charges reported by Indiana State Police, the 42 felony counts include thirteen of Level 6 forgery, two of Level 6 counterfeiting, five of Level 5 fraud against a financial institution, and twenty-two spread across Level 6 fraud, fraud with enhancing circumstances, and theft involving amounts between $750 and $50,000, plus one misdemeanor fraud count and two misdemeanor theft counts. Prosecutors filed the charges on October 14, 2026; Textor was taken into custody the next day and transported to the Lake County Jail. CBS News Chicago reported bail set at $150,000 with 10 percent required for release. A subsequent hearing was scheduled for October 20. Charges do not establish that she committed the alleged offenses; she is presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty.
Why a document that looks official does not change your legal status
Criminal-record expungement in Indiana is a legal process that may seal or restrict certain criminal history information from public access, and eligibility depends on the type of offense, the case outcome, the passage of time, and compliance with applicable requirements — not every conviction qualifies for the same relief. A petition must go to the appropriate court, and if the court grants relief, it issues an official order that the agencies then process. A document that appears official does not itself change a person's legal status. Any copy, letterhead, or completion notice can be produced without a court order ever existing, which is exactly what investigators allege occurred here. A paid receipt or a filing confirmation from a third party is not the same artifact as the order the court actually entered.
How to verify that a record was actually cleared
Three checks separate a real sealing from a convincing piece of paper. The first is direct confirmation from the court: contact the clerk of the court where the case was filed and ask whether an expungement order was entered, and on what date. That is the source of truth, and it is the check this case shows was never performed. The second is confirmation from the state repository that holds the criminal history record — in Indiana, the Indiana State Police — because a court order that has not been processed leaves the record live in the system employers' background checks read. The third is a refreshed background report obtained after the order date, rather than a screenshot or an earlier report. Indiana State Police believe the scheme may have affected additional individuals who have not yet been identified, and have asked anyone who believes they may have been affected to contact Sgt. Joe White at 219-696-6242. Anyone whose paperwork indicated restored driving privileges should confirm that status with the Bureau of Motor Vehicles.
What to watch for next
The case will produce a fuller public record as the proceedings continue, and Indiana State Police have said additional charges are under review. The wider question for expungement reform is what this does to the assumption that a person's own diligence is the last line of defense. Automated and petition-based sealing systems reduce the number of court appearances a person must make, and that is the correct direction. But every version of record clearing depends on the same final step: a government agency acting on an official order, and the person being able to confirm it happened. When the verification step is skipped, the failure does not stay contained to a financial loss. It reaches into driving privileges, employment screening, and the physical custody of people who believed their records were closed.