Clean Slate Guide

What good is a court order expunging a criminal conviction if an employer, landlord or prospective customer can type a name into Google and immediately encounter a decades-old record with no indication that a judge has legally expunged it?

What Indiana's Expungement Law Already Does

Indiana lawmakers have built a statutory system intended to give qualifying people relief from the continuing consequences of past criminal cases. Judges review petitions, determine eligibility and issue expungement orders under Indiana Code § 35-38-9. The law promises meaningful relief, including restrictions on disclosure, employment discrimination and the use of expunged records.

Under § 35-38-9-10, qualifying individuals whose records have been expunged generally must be treated as though they had never been convicted, subject to important statutory exceptions. The law also prohibits specified forms of discrimination based on expunged records, including certain employment, licensing and educational decisions. For some expungements, records must be sealed. For others, particularly certain more serious felony convictions, records remain publicly accessible but must be clearly marked as expunged. The General Assembly therefore already recognizes two essential principles: some criminal histories should no longer be publicly accessible, and other histories must be presented with their updated legal status.

Where the Promise Stops

Those protections are incomplete if private databases and search engines keep presenting old information without reflecting what the courts have since ordered. A judge can order the state's official records corrected, sealed or marked, and that does not necessarily mean every privately maintained webpage or search result will be corrected. The result can be a digital contradiction: Indiana law recognizes an expungement, while an internet search keeps presenting the old conviction without context. A conviction may be expunged in the courthouse but remain effectively permanent in the search engine.

Search engines do not decide whether someone qualifies for expungement. Indiana's courts do. But an outdated search snippet may be the first, and sometimes only, information a potential employer or business associate encounters. The problem becomes serious when a result inaccurately describes an expunged conviction as current, omits a later dismissal, or fails to reflect a judicial order that fundamentally changed a person's legal status.

The Five Protections a State Statute Would Need

Indiana should examine how to close that gap with legislation ensuring judicial expungement orders receive meaningful recognition throughout the commercial criminal-history information industry. A carefully drafted statute should establish five protections.

First, mandatory correction of commercial criminal-history reports. Any company that sells or distributes criminal-history information for employment, housing, licensing or similar decisions should be required to verify expungement status and correct covered records promptly after receiving authenticated notice.

Second, an enforceable correction process for search results. Search providers should offer a clear mechanism for individuals to submit valid expungement orders and identify results that inaccurately describe a conviction's current legal status. The legislature should examine whether a correction deadline can lawfully apply to covered commercial services.

Third, removal or correction of outdated government-source information. When an Indiana court seals or redacts a record, state agencies should ensure public-facing databases are updated promptly. Official systems should not keep publishing information a court has ordered withheld.

Fourth, stronger remedies for repeated violations. Where commercial criminal-history providers knowingly continue distributing prohibited information after authenticated notice, individuals should have meaningful avenues for enforcement, including statutory damages and attorney fees where constitutionally and legally appropriate.

Fifth, accountability for data brokers. Companies that obtain criminal-history data in bulk should have reasonable obligations to maintain accurate legal-status information rather than selling obsolete records indefinitely.

Why Federal Law Limits the Fix

These proposals must distinguish general search engines from specialized background-check companies. Federal law, including Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act, and First Amendment protections may limit what Indiana can compel a search engine or news publisher to remove. Federal consumer-reporting law may also apply to some criminal-history products. A serious legislative effort has to address those limits rather than promise remedies courts cannot enforce.

There is also a distinction worth preserving between truthful historical reporting and the continued distribution of materially misleading information. The public has legitimate interests in journalism, historical records and government accountability, and expungement should not become a device for erasing accurate reporting about matters of public concern. Nor should every old article automatically become unlawful merely because the underlying conviction was expunged. But there is no sound public-policy reason to treat a demonstrably outdated criminal-history listing as immune from correction when an individual supplies an authenticated court order establishing current legal status.

A 30-Day Deadline for Commercial Providers

For covered commercial criminal-history providers, Indiana should consider requiring correction or removal within 30 days after receipt of an authenticated expungement order. That deadline should be paired with safeguards against fraudulent submissions, mistaken identity, and suppression of information that remains legally public. For general search engines, the state should explore a separate procedure addressing demonstrably false or outdated legal-status representations, with judicial review before coercive penalties are imposed. The goal should not be to rewrite history, but to prevent the continued commercial use of records in ways that contradict their present legal status.

What a Person With an Expungement Can Do Now

A person who successfully petitions for expungement has completed a legal process established by the General Assembly. That person should not have to spend years contacting websites, paying reputation-management companies, and explaining an obsolete conviction to every prospective employer. Google offers procedures for requesting removal of certain outdated or legally objectionable search results, but those procedures are not the same as a uniform statutory obligation to update every expunged record within a defined period.

The legislature should also study how frequently expunged records continue appearing in online background checks, how long corrections take, and whether existing enforcement mechanisms provide effective relief. These questions concern more than convenience. They affect employment, housing, professional licensing, financial opportunity, and the credibility of the judicial system itself. A second chance that exists only in a court file is an incomplete second chance, and the public should not have to choose between freedom of information and the meaningful enforcement of judicial relief.

Quick Action

Find a Lawyer in Your State

Browse attorney directories by state, or check your eligibility first.

Find a Lawyer → Or check your eligibility first

No signup required. Free to browse.

Your State

View all 50 states

Was This Helpful?