Clean Slate Guide

For most readers of this site, a "record" means something a court can erase: an expungement order, or an automatic sealing statute. A marijuana conviction creates a second, parallel record that expungement does not address. If the conviction makes a person deportable under federal immigration law, it can put them in detention years after the sentence ends — and in 2026, federal judges in three states have ruled that this cannot happen without a bond hearing.

Two Questions That Are Easily Confused

These rulings separate two questions that usually run together. The first is whether a conviction counts as a drug offense under federal law. The second is whether the government can detain someone without a bond hearing — an individualized chance to argue they are not a flight risk and not a danger to the community. Two of the three courts below reached the hearing question without ever deciding the first.

Colorado: A Conviction That Finished Did Not End the Detention

Ronald Alexander Castaneda Aguirre, who was born in El Salvador, had previously been released from immigration custody on a $2,500 bond in July 2023. Following his June 2025 convictions for marijuana possession and DUI, he completed his criminal sentence but was transferred directly into immigration detention without receiving a new bond hearing. In an order issued October 27, U.S. District Judge Philip Brimmer directed federal officials to release him within 48 hours.

The court found that the government had failed to establish why his detention was necessary: federal authorities did not argue that his convictions required mandatory detention, and officials did not demonstrate that he posed a flight risk or danger to the community. Brimmer concluded that the detention violated the Fifth Amendment's due process protections. The holding is narrower than a ruling about the convictions: where the government asserts neither mandatory detention nor a flight risk, the absence of the hearing itself can be a due process violation.

Michigan: A Hearing That Did Not Happen

A federal judge in Michigan reached a similar conclusion on November 6. U.S. District Judge Paul L. Maloney of the Western District of Michigan found that the prolonged detention of Helio Farinas Wong, a Cuban national convicted of possession of marijuana with intent to distribute in 2017, violated the Fifth Amendment's due process protections. ICE arrested Farinas Wong on January 8, 2026, and an immigration judge ordered his removal to Cuba on March 26, but his appeal remains pending before the Board of Immigration Appeals.

Federal immigration officials argued that his marijuana conviction subjected him to mandatory detention under federal immigration law, meaning he was not entitled to a standard bond hearing. Maloney determined that although the government could potentially rely on mandatory detention provisions, prolonged confinement without an opportunity to challenge the necessity of detention raises separate constitutional concerns. The court also emphasized that immigration detention is intended to ensure that individuals attend removal proceedings and do not pose a danger to the community, rather than serve as punishment. The ruling establishes that his nearly 10-month detention without an individualized bond hearing exceeded constitutional limits.

The order is concrete. Immigration authorities must provide Farinas Wong with a bond hearing within five business days of November 6 or immediately release him from custody, and must submit a compliance report within six business days detailing whether the hearing occurred and whether bond was granted or denied. The limits are explicit: the decision does not overturn his marijuana conviction or resolve his underlying immigration case, and it does not guarantee his release if an immigration judge finds continued detention warranted.

California: When the State Law Was Broader Than Federal Law

The third decision took a different route. In an October 29 ruling, U.S. District Judge Mary K. Dimke of the Eastern District of California ordered federal immigration authorities to provide a detained man with an individualized bond hearing within 10 days, and directed that he be released if the government fails to provide the hearing within that period, unless he requests an extension.

The case involves a man identified in court documents as Josue R.R., who was arrested in Texas on January 31, 2019, for possessing more than two ounces but no more than four ounces of marijuana. He pleaded guilty in April 2021, received deferred adjudication and community supervision, and successfully completed that supervision in October 2022. According to the court, he had been complying with immigration reporting requirements before ICE detained him during a scheduled check-in on July 23, 2026.

The dispute centered on a difference between state and federal marijuana definitions that existed for nearly six months in 2018 and 2019. Congress removed hemp from the federal Controlled Substances Act's definition of marijuana on December 20, 2018, through the 2018 Farm Bill. Texas did not adopt its corresponding exclusion until June 10, 2019, several months after the man's arrest. The judge determined that the change applied only to offenses committed after the state's amendment took effect, so the earlier Texas statute still covered hemp products that federal law no longer classified as marijuana.

As a result, the judge concluded that the conviction did not establish the mandatory detention ground the government asserted, and the custody falls under a federal provision allowing an immigration judge to consider release on bond. The government must demonstrate through clear and convincing evidence that the man presents a flight risk or danger to the community. The ruling applies only to this case and sets no binding precedent, but its reasoning could matter in similar cases involving older convictions under state laws that included federally legal hemp.

What a Reader With a Marijuana Conviction Should Take From This

None of these rulings erases a conviction, and none of them is a substitute for expungement. What they establish is narrower and still meaningful: a marijuana conviction is a serious immigration consequence, but it is not a blank check for indefinite detention without a hearing.

The date of the offense can matter in ways that are invisible in the criminal record itself. The California decision turned on the months between the federal hemp change and the Texas state change. The amount of substance is a separate variable, and none of these rulings resolves the question for everyone else.

What a detained person can act on is the hearing itself: these decisions show courts willing to treat the absence of a bond hearing as a due process problem. If a conviction is still on your record and eligible for expungement, the state-court path remains available — and it is the one that actually removes the record from view.

Quick Action

Find a Lawyer in Your State

Browse attorney directories by state, or check your eligibility first.

Find a Lawyer → Or check your eligibility first

No signup required. Free to browse.

Your State

View all 50 states

Was This Helpful?